| Finals |
| Brian Letters MD1st | MED. FORFEIT | Josh Asper Unattached2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | 6-4 | Jason Coyne NAVY |
| Tim Darling PSU | 4-2 | Sli Bostelman Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Brian Letters MD | 4-2 | Matt DeMichiel NAVY |
| Josh Asper Unattached | 5-3 | Jason Lapham RIDER |
| Consi 4 |
| Tim Darling PSU | PIN 4:08 | Chris Hrunka Unattached |
| Sli Bostelman Unattached | 5-2 | Chad Porter Unattached |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | 12-2 | Matt Pletcher RU |
| Jason Coyne NAVY | 8-1 | Brad Clark LIB |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Chris Hrunka Unattached | 8-6 | Zach Mckendree Unattached |
| Jason Coyne NAVY | MED. FORFEIT | Brandon Hatchett LEH |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | PIN 3:26 | Corey Lear Unattached |
| Sli Bostelman Unattached | 10-1 | Aaron Keeton GMU |
| Quarterfinal |
| Matt DeMichiel NAVY | 9-1 | Matt Pletcher RU |
| Brian Letters MD | 7-2 | Brad Clark LIB |
| Jason Lapham RIDER | 6-5 | — |
| Josh Asper Unattached | 12-10 | Tim Darling PSU |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Sli Bostelman Unattached | 6-3 | Thomas Timothy PENN |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | 8-2 | Ryan McGarity BING |
| Aaron Keeton GMU | 6-2 | Sean Quinn Wagner College |
| Zach Mckendree Unattached | 15-3 | Matt Gregg DUQ |
| Jason Coyne NAVY | PIN 0:22 | Tony Bradberry Ashland University |
| Chris Hrunka Unattached | PIN 2:41 | Derek Sickel CIT |
| Corey Lear Unattached | PIN 5:22 | Michael Brant NAVY |
| Brandon Hatchett LEH | 5-3 | Kramer Whitelaw GMU |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Zach Mckendree Unattached | PIN 2:52 | Tim Buirkle Unattached |
| Tony Bradberry Ashland University | FORFEIT | Mark Friend PSU |
| Derek Sickel CIT | PIN 5:21 | Joe Vitucci Wagner College |
| Corey Lear Unattached | 9-1 | Michael Digiorgio BING |
| Sean Quinn Wagner College | 3-1 | Dustin Doty Cleveland State University |
| Brandon Hatchett LEH | FORFEIT | Ken Carney Unattached |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | 5-4 | Zach Lundgren PITT-J |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | 17-1 | Brandon Brookens PSU CLUB |
| Round of 16 |
| Josh Asper Unattached | 12-3 | Jason Coyne NAVY |
| Brian Letters MD | 18-9 | Matt Gregg DUQ |
| Tim Darling PSU | 9-4 | Kramer Whitelaw GMU |
| Matt Pletcher RU | 6-2 | Sli Bostelman Unattached |
| Chad Porter Unattached | 9-6 | Ryan McGarity BING |
| Brad Clark LIB | 5-1 | Chris Hrunka Unattached |
| Matt DeMichiel NAVY | 8-3 | Aaron Keeton GMU |
| Round of 32 |
| Chad Porter Unattached | 8-0 | Zach Mckendree Unattached |
| Jason Coyne NAVY | PIN 6:24 | Zach Lundgren PITT-J |
| Sli Bostelman Unattached | 7-3 | Tony Bradberry Ashland University |
| Ryan McGarity BING | 14-4 | Tim Buirkle Unattached |
| Brad Clark LIB | 4-2 | Corey Lear Unattached |
| Matt Pletcher RU | 3-2 | Mark Friend PSU |
| Michael Brant NAVY | 15-1 | Joe Vitucci Wagner College |
| Kramer Whitelaw GMU | PIN 2:05 | Dustin Doty Cleveland State University |
| Matt Gregg DUQ | 5-4 | Brandon Brookens PSU CLUB |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Sean Quinn Wagner College | 7-6 | Warner Phipps COR |
| Kramer Whitelaw GMU | PIN 3:48 | Kevin Dufresne Unattached |
| Matt Pletcher RU | 4-0 | Kyle Keane PITT-J |
| Corey Lear Unattached | 5-2 | Manny Hickson Unattached |
| Aaron Keeton GMU | 7-5 | Alex Rinaldi DREX |
| Tim Buirkle Unattached | 8-0 | Shane Donnelly Unattached |
| Matt DeMichiel NAVY | 11-4 | C.J. Inglin Boston University |
| Derek Sickel CIT | PIN 1:51 | Tom O'Connor Unattached |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | 6-1 | Steven Cressley Unattached |
|
