| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Adam Whetstone PITT-J | 12-2 | Mike Hromada Unattached |
| Kareem Naguib BING | 15-0 | Andrew Ferguson GALLAUDET |
| Jayk Cobbs DUQ | 12-2 | Brendan Keys Unattached |
| Matt Pagan NAVY | 7-0 | Lawrence Cavello Cleveland State University |
| John Delgado GMU | 14-4 | Jarret Freeman Unattached |
| Jake Shirk PITT-J | 12-2 | Levi Smeltzer Unattached |
| Dustin Haislip NAVY | PIN 0:47 | Christian Fagan PITT |
| Derek Royster CIT | 4-0 | Colby Pisani PSU |
| Josh Dziewa Unattached | 6-0 | John Majka NAVY |
| Ryan Goddu Boston University | 12-8 | David Wise Unattached |
| Tyler Young Cleveland State University | 10-2 | Ryan Cornell Wagner College |
| Corey Bowers Unattached | PIN 1:00 | Kyle Kanaga Unattached |
| John Regan Unattached | PIN 5:42 | Dave Crown Unattached |
| Tim Rich Unattached | 15-0 | Ian Desole BLOOM |
| Don Miller Unattached | 15-0 | Kyle Vincelli Unattached |
| David Ivashchenko CIT | PIN 2:21 | Andrew Cohen Unattached |