| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Kelby Smith CIT | PIN 4:34 | Peter Morano Wagner College |
| Christopher Orzechowski RU | 9-2 | Matt Latessa FM |
| Rob Waltko Unattached | 5-3 | Andy Vaughan PITT |
| Joshua Patterson BING | PIN 4:07 | Phil Bomberger PSU |
| Jimmy Webb GMU | 5-1 | Travis Stem LHU |
| Greg Prioleau NAVY | 8-4 | Brian Hurley CIT |
| Travis Dale COR | PIN 4:47 | Robert Prigmore Unattached |
| Casey Caldwell NAVY | 7-1 | Zach Ulm GMU |
| Nate Holley COR | FORFEIT | Jeremie Cook Unattached |
| Kadeem Samuels LEH | PIN 1:10 | Mikal McKee Unattached |
| Keith Dobish RU | 3-2 | Eric Fulmer Unattached |
| McPaul Ogbonna Unattached | 6-3 | Carmen Rondash Boston University |
| Chris Daggett LIB | 6-2 | Anthony Tortora HOF |
| Brock Mantella PITT | 7-0 | Chris Lloyd MD |
| Bill Widener GMU | 4-3 | Kevin Beazley Unattached |
| Robert Piscitello HOF | 4-1 | Dan Kennedy Boston University |