| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Daniel Genetin Ashland University | 6-4 | Corey Bowers Unattached |
| Josh Dziewa Unattached | 15-6 | Don Miller Unattached |
| John Regan Unattached | 10-2 | Jake Shirk PITT-J |
| Jayk Cobbs DUQ | 7-6 | Anthony Jerome Unattached |
| Ryan Goddu Boston University | PIN 6:25 | Kareem Naguib BING |
| Fred Rodgers RIDER | 5-2 | Patrick Wieger Unattached |
| Derek Royster CIT | 8-1 | Zach Kell LHU |
| Dustin Haislip NAVY | 12-2 | Adam Whetstone PITT-J |