| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Zach Mckendree Unattached | PIN 2:52 | Tim Buirkle Unattached |
| Tony Bradberry Ashland University | FORFEIT | Mark Friend PSU |
| Derek Sickel CIT | PIN 5:21 | Joe Vitucci Wagner College |
| Corey Lear Unattached | 9-1 | Michael Digiorgio BING |
| Sean Quinn Wagner College | 3-1 | Dustin Doty Cleveland State University |
| Brandon Hatchett LEH | FORFEIT | Ken Carney Unattached |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | 5-4 | Zach Lundgren PITT-J |
| Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University | 17-1 | Brandon Brookens PSU CLUB |