| Raymond Jordan MIZZ | PIN 5:31 | Kevin Flinn UINDY |
| Cody Hill OKST | DEC 7-5 | Dan McGee UCM |
| Anthony Enyobi Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Ryan DesRoches POLY |
| Ben Friedl ILL | DEC 6-5 | Nick Avery IND |
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University | PIN 6:56 | Josh Bryant McKendree University |
| Mike Kelly Harper College | DEC 7-1 | Conor Fitzgerald UCM |
| Clinton Polz ILL | DEC 6-1 | Daniel Morrison University of Central Oklahoma |
| Alton Lucas HOF | DEC 6-3 | Kevin Wainscott OKST |