| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Consolation | ||
| Alec Bonander Luther College | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Tyler Dickenson Unattached |
| Jake Cranford ASU | PIN 1:40 | Justin Kuhn Unattached |
| Scott Penny NIU | DEC 6-0 | Ethan Winel CHAT |
| Chad Hanke ORST | DEC 14-8 | James Ciccone AF |
| Alec Bonander Luther College | DEC 10-4 | Matthew Wilps PITT |
| John McClure EMU | DEC 8-2 | Vincent Bordi San Francisco State University |
| A.J. Hunte Unattached | DEC 4-3 | Derek Ross University of Nebraska at Kearney |
| Tyler Smith RIDER | PIN 2:48 | Jake Norman Unattached |
| John Schoen NW | DEC 5-4 | Matt Wonderlin University of Dubuque |
| Andrew Anderson UNI | DEC 5-2 | Jake Cranford ASU |
| Matt Powless IND | DEC 12-5 | Scott Penny NIU |
| Chad Hanke ORST | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Rick Loera Unattached |
| Alec Bonander Luther College | DEC 13-8 | Andrew Silber AU |
| Patrick Bond ILL | DEC 11-6 | John McClure EMU |
| A.J. Hunte Unattached | DEC 4-3 | Eric Simaz CMU |
| Lamar Brown Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Tyler Smith RIDER |
| Brodie Ambrose Unattached | DEC 3-2 | John Schoen NW |
| Andrew Anderson UNI | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Matt Powless IND |
| Alec Bonander Luther College | PIN 5:52 | Chad Hanke ORST |
| Patrick Bond ILL | PIN 1:17 | A.J. Hunte Unattached |
| Lamar Brown Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Brodie Ambrose Unattached |
| Logan Brown PUR | DEC 3-1 | Andrew Anderson UNI |
| Kyle Simonson Unattached | DEC 6-4 | Alec Bonander Luther College |
| Jesse Strawn ODU | DEC 5-2 | Patrick Bond ILL |
| Hudson Taylor MD | PIN 6:00 | Lamar Brown Unattached |
| Logan Brown PUR | PIN 2:53 | Kyle Simonson Unattached |
| Jesse Strawn ODU | PIN 4:29 | Hudson Taylor MD |
| Logan Brown PUR | FORFEIT | Trevor Brandvold Unattached |
| Max Askren MIZZ | MAJ DEC 11-6 | Jesse Strawn ODU |