| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Devon Smith HOF | PIN 4:30 | Bryan Dine |
| Brandon Williamson | PIN 2:24 | Ed Backus Unattached |
| Andrew Knapp HARV | PIN 2:49 | John Gabordi Springfield College |
| Chris Brown | PIN 0:42 | Dan Bittner Unattached |
| Ryan Cook | PIN 4:35 | Tinos Travlos Unattached |
| Ryan Flores COLU | PIN 4:05 | Shane Meighan DREX |
| Bill Beirmeister SHU | PIN 4:04 | Larry Otsuka BRWN |
| Maciej Jochym Unattached | PIN 1:01 | Aldin Chapman SHU |
| Bryant Deinhardt DREX | PIN 1:44 | Guillano Vilgrain |
| Zach Hammond Unattached | DEC 8-3 | Zachary Walsh BLOOM |
| Jim Conners SHU | DEC 2-1 | Corey James Unattached |
| Lukasz Stala Unattached | DEC 11-5 | Stephen Turner PRIN |
| DJ Russo RU | DEC 4-2 | Oney Snyder Unattached |
| Sam Cervantes Naval Academy Prep School | DEC 4-0 | Art Garvey Unattached |
| Zach Zorada BRWN | DEC 6-2 | Joe Murphy SUNY-Cortland |
| Sean Dedeyn Unattached | DEC 5-2 | Spencer DeSena HARV |