| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Troy Nickerson Unattached | F 1:26 | Robert Benitez PRIN |
| Fred Santaite SHU | F 0:42 | James Punnulo RU |
| Kyle Gilchrist COLU | DEC 10-1 | Brian Borst COLU |
| Rocardo Gomez SHU | DEC 14-0 | Ryan Dowd BRWN |
| Gabe Roman Unattached | DEC 12-1 | Glenn Donatelli Unattached |
| Thomas Williams Unattached | DEC 3-0 | Matthew Snyder SUNY-Cortland |
| Drew Bloss BRWN | DEC 9-4 | TJ Popolizio BRWN |
| Frank Perrelli COLU | DEC 13-4 | Corey Borshoff Unattached |
| Michael Piccirillo BRWN | DEC 4-2 | Casey Leslie AU |
| Joe Langle Unattached | DEC 18-2 | Tyler Malmberg Unattached |
| Mike DeMarco Unattached | F 2:00 | Dylon Huddleston RU |
| Lance Penhale ARMY | FOR | Tim Clarke AU |
| Greg Einfrank SHU | DEC 10-5 | Jesse Sgaglione BRWN |
| Kevin Tao SHU | F 4:57 | Michael Impellizeri SHU |
| Steve Mytych DREX | DEC 16-2 | Paul Galipeau SHU |
| Matt Fusco Unattached | F 2:05 | Cory Krimmer Unattached |