| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Travis Coffey ARMY | PIN 3:59 | DeSean Willis Cumberland University |
| Mike Picirillo BRWN | DEC 6-3 | Joshua Seeley Dakota Wesleyan University |
| Derek Reber BUCK | DEC 8-1 | Andy Pokorny NEB |
| Curtis Schurkamp San Francisco State University | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Jimmy Marx Northern State University |