| James Williamson MIZZ | FORFEIT | Nick Hayes NW |
| Vince Demarest MIZZ | DEC 4-1 | Ben Ellard Campbellsville University |
| Joey Garrity MIZZ | DEC 3-1 | Ben Friedl ILL |
| Nick Pullano ODU | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Jesse Sheets UCM |
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University | MAJ DEC 19-5 | Clinton Polz ILL |
| John Andrews MIZZ | DEC 9-2 | Travis Barbarick UCM |
| Ryan Sonderegger MIZZ | DEC 4-3 | Kenny Meredith University of Central Oklahoma |
| John Dergo ILL | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Chris Branam Campbellsville University |