| Ryan Lang Unattached | MAJ DEC 16-3 | Kurt Kinser IND |
| Colby Robinson University of Central Oklahoma | DEC 5-2 | Matt Lee ILL |
| Andrew Nadhir NW | PIN 4:38 | Ashtin Primus MIZZ |
| Ryan Moyer Lindenwood University | PIN 1:43 | Herschel Tendler McKendree University |
| David Cayce Lindenwood University | FORFEIT | Josh Wagner MIZZ |
| Nick Walpole IND | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Chad Woods UINDY |
| Dan Zeman ILL | DEC 12-10 | Brent Sarette University of Central Oklahoma |
| Kaylen Baxter ODU | DEC 8-3 | Marty Gould NW |