| Ryan Williams ODU | PIN 6:19 | Jesse Whitson Unattached |
| Justin Cole MIZZ | DEC 3-1 | Kyle Norred Campbellsville University |
| Alex Warren IND | PIN 1:19 | Grant Baker UCM |
| Willie Saxton MIZZ | DEC 8-7 | Caleb Lockyer Lindenwood University |
| Marcus Hoehn MIZZ | MAJ DEC 16-3 | Marc Antoni Macias Campbellsville University |
| Ryan Joyce Lindenwood University | PIN 5:20 | Cory Bloodgood UCM |
| Vince Hannon MIZZ | DEC 5-4 | Kyle Jahn McKendree University |
| Zack Bailey Unattached | DEC 10-5 | Scott Kelly IND |