| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Emanuel Brooks MIZZ | DEC 7-4 | Rob Morrison RIDER |
| Jason Welch Unattached | PIN 1:36 | Blake Reed SIUE |
| Nick Bertucci PUR | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Jay Milz Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Seth Garvin CHAT | TF 16-0 | Ben Boudro MSU |
| Pete Puckett CMU | DEC 6-5 | Bryan O'Connor NIU |
| Paul Young IND | PIN 4:34 | Kyle Katz Elmhurst University |
| Andrew Sherry MIZZ | PIN 2:57 | Robbie Micheals Cleveland State University |
| Darren Olsen Lincoln College | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Travis Eggers Peacock WC |
| Wayne French Great Falls | PIN 4:27 | Chris Kelly Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| John Fulger MSU | PIN 6:33 | Jeremy Eduard Illinois State WC |
| Tyler Grayson CMU | DEC 4-3 | Jason Brew Olivet College |
| Christopher Stout AU | TF 20-4 | Seth Pugh UNI |
| Cyler Sanderson ISU | PIN 6:48 | Anthony Dorward AF |