| Consi 16 #1 |
| Ryan Etherton University of Nebraska at Kearney | DEC 3-1 | Joey Ecklof PITT |
| Josh Nolan San Francisco State University | DEC 6-1 | Matt Mitchell SIUE |
| Ryan Hurley Cleveland State University | PIN 1:51 | Nick Pitas AU |
| Charlie Ettelson UNI | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Christopher Szabolcs AF |
| Byron Kuylen Montana State - Northern | DEC 5-2 | Matt Dunn COLU |
| Nick LeClere IOWA | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Kyle Cunningham SIUE |
| Joey Kotowsky ILL | DEC 8-1 | Jeff Kastel Elmhurst University |
| Kalen Knull NIU | DEC 3-2 | Jeff Harman University of Chicago |
| Nick Pickerell UNI | PIN 1:06 | Jarred Tribbett Wabash College |
| Joey Deaguero Adams State | PIN 5:00 | Andrew Nadhir NW |
| Johansen Quist Luther College | DEC 6-5 | Justin Hale Lincoln College |
| Will McDearmitt NIU | DEC 6-0 | Nick DiCarlo Anderson University (SC) |
| Ashtin Primus MIZZ | PIN 1:01 | Brian Spangler PENN |
| Mark Ballweg IOWA | PIN 2:39 | Craig Johnson Harper College |
| Eddie Skowneski MSU | TF 16-0 | Vince Tucker Olivet College |
| Matt Wahl Elmhurst University | FORFEIT | Ryan Lang NW |
