| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Dave Gualtieri | ||
| DEC 6-5 |
| Morgan Wanzer AIC |
| Dave Gualtieri DREX | DEC 9-2 | Matt Cury Husky Wrestling Club |
| Kyle Davis Kutztown University | PIN 2:20 | AJ Rosenburg UVA |
| Treavor LeBlanc SUNY-Cortland | DEC 2-1 | Joe DeGaravilla UVA |
| Justin Wieller DREX | TF 16-1 | Victor Montanez Kutztown University |
| Jon Rothman HOF | DEC 3-2 | Charlie Wonsettler BUCK |
| Nate Holley COR | DEC 11-5 | Kyle Davis Kutztown University |
| Michael Moore DAV | DEC 4-1 | Justin Danz HOF |
| Justin Danz HOF | DEC 5-3 | Matt Berretta BING |
| Andrew Silber AU | MAJ DEC 14-1 | Jon Rothman HOF |
| Justin Kerber COR | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Jamie Facenda UVA |
| Travis Dale COR | DEC 2-1 | Anthony Esposito BING |
| Rocco Caponi UVA | DEC 3-1 | Justin Wieller DREX |
| Justin Kerber COR | PIN 0:21 | Jay Chaika AIC |