| Finals |
| Nick Simmons MSU1st | 4-3 | Jake Strayer PSU2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Matt Kyler ARMY | 9-5 | Steve Fittery SHIP |
| Semifinal |
| Jake Strayer PSU | 6-4 | Joe Kemmerer Kutztown University |
| Nick Simmons MSU | 12-0 | Mike Grey Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Danny Lopes LHU | 3-2 | Brad Cipriani DUQ |
| Steve Fittery SHIP | 3-2 | Chris Notte Nassau Community College |
| Matt Kyler ARMY | 7-3 | Joey Whitaker Boston University |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Sam Walters LIB | PIN 5:42 | Rob LaBrake Unattached |
| Brad Cipriani DUQ | 6-4 | Bryan Gibson DUKE |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 5-3 | Kyle Fluke Unattached |
| Joey Whitaker Boston University | PIN 3:31 | Anwar Goeres Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Joe Kemmerer Kutztown University | 3-1 | Steve Fittery SHIP |
| Jake Strayer PSU | 6-1 | Matt Kyler ARMY |
| Nick Simmons MSU | 15-0 | Terreyl Williams APP |
| Mike Grey Unattached | 5-2 | Danny Lopes LHU |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Sam Walters LIB | 6-1 | Chris Robbins PSU |
| Anwar Goeres Unattached | FORFEIT | David Armstrong Cleveland State University |
| Bryan Gibson DUKE | 9-6 | Stephen Perez Nassau Community College |
| Joey Whitaker Boston University | 11-5 | Kareem Naguib BING |
| Rob LaBrake Unattached | PIN 4:26 | Jayk Cobbs DUQ |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 7-3 | Adam Whetstone PITT-J |
| Brad Cipriani DUQ | 5-1 | William Simpson ARMY |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 3-1 | Shad Rissler King University |
| William Simpson ARMY | 5-3 | Tyler Leljedal CLAR |
| Joel Trombly Unattached | 9-1 | Mike Paronish Unattached |
| Jayk Cobbs DUQ | 12-1 | Joe Wilson BUFF |
| Joey Whitaker Boston University | 5-1 | Mike Sears Unattached |
| Stephen Perez Nassau Community College | 4-1 | Paul Hallowell GHSA |
| David Armstrong Cleveland State University | 11-3 | Erik Smith LHU |
| Chris Robbins PSU | 5-2 | Kwinten Brown King University |
| Round of 16 |
| Steve Fittery SHIP | 10-4 | Bryan Gibson DUKE |
| Terreyl Williams APP | PIN 3:31 | Anwar Goeres Unattached |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 0:43 | Sam Walters LIB |
| Matt Kyler ARMY | 3-1 | Rob LaBrake Unattached |
| Joe Kemmerer Kutztown University | 3-0 | Brad Cipriani DUQ |
| Nick Simmons MSU | 9-4 | Kareem Naguib BING |
| Danny Lopes LHU | 5-3 | Kyle Fluke Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Matt Kyler ARMY | 16-7 | Joel Trombly Unattached |
| Rob LaBrake Unattached | 7-1 | Mike Paronish Unattached |
| Steve Fittery SHIP | 14-1 | Mike Sears Unattached |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 3:41 | Chris Notte Nassau Community College |
| Adam Whetstone PITT-J | 11-4 | Chris Robbins PSU |
| Nick Simmons MSU | 12-2 | Paul Hallowell GHSA |
| Brad Cipriani DUQ | 5-1 | David Armstrong Cleveland State University |
| Danny Lopes LHU | 10-5 | Jayk Cobbs DUQ |
| Joe Kemmerer Kutztown University | PIN 1:51 | Erik Smith LHU |
| Bryan Gibson |
| Round of 64 |
| William Simpson ARMY | 2-0 | Jeremy Shaw UNC |
| Jake Strayer PSU | 16-1 | Zach Anderson UVA |
| Kareem Naguib BING | 4-1 | Zach McCray LIB |
| Nick Simmons MSU | PIN 1:54 | Corey Hamabata COR |
| Matt Kyler ARMY | PIN 3:13 | Matthew Maris Unattached |
| Joe Kemmerer Kutztown University | 7-2 | Bobby Shaw UNC |
| Steve Fittery SHIP | 5-0 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Kyle Fluke Unattached | 17-0 | Chris Weiller Kutztown University |
| Terreyl Williams APP | 11-4 | Brian Polashuk Unattached |
| Bryan Gibson |
