| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Mike Ferrara Unattached | 3-1 | Brian Shaw Unattached |
| Neal Martin APP | 1-0 | Eli Vidal Boston University |
| John Murphy MSU | 9-6 | Scott Hunter Unattached |
| Justin Kerber Unattached | 7-2 | Curtis Beardsell Unattached |
| David Sullivan Unattached | 15-0 | Jeremy Brooks MVILLE |
| Scott Joseph CLAR | 5-2 | Anthony Esposito Unattached |
| Scott Giffin Unattached | 5-1 | Chris Estep Unattached |
| Matt Palmer Unattached | 5-0 | Alex Caruso Unattached |
| Rick Mascino SHIP | 12-5 | Samuel Eck Unattached |
| Dustin McCabe VMI | 2-1 | Mike Whalen RU |
| Joshua Patterson BING | 9-1 | Derek Coffey ODU |
| Brent Smith ARMY | 7-1 | Bradley Nielson Unattached |
| Alex Iacocca LEH | 7-5 | Alex Dalrymple Unattached |
| Christopher Henrich GERMANTOWN ACADEMY | 7-2 | Ben Nicholas NAVY |
| James Yonushonis PSU | 3-1 | Kyle Walters LIB |
| Matt Stolpinski NAVY | 11-4 | Steve Ratley VT |