| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Josh Tyler ODU | MED. FORFEIT | Nathan Owens Unattached |
| Kirk Landon Army Prep | 9-2 | Dimitri Laurent Boston University |
| Aaron Kelley LIB | 5-4 | Jack Barrett RU |
| Hadley Harrison CLAR | 5-2 | Nate Patterson BING |
| Jared Mellott Unattached | 4-3 | Shaun Mitchell Cleveland State University |
| Danny Artusio Unattached | 12-3 | Brian Petrakis Unattached |
| Brain Cook PITT-J | MED. FORFEIT | Bryce Saddoris Unattached |
| Nick Fallico MSU | 9-7 | Kyle Fried BING |