| Finals |
| Mark McKnight PSU1st | 5-3 | Franklin Gomez MSU2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Matt Fisk Unattached | 3-2 | Fernando Martinez ARMY |
| Semifinal |
| Franklin Gomez MSU | 17-1 | PJ Puriefoy King University |
| Mark McKnight PSU | 14-4 | James Nicholson Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Alex Usztics NAVY | 6-0 | Whitt Dunning ARMY |
| Fernando Martinez ARMY | 10-8 | Roger Peterkin PENN |
| Matt Fisk Unattached | 13-0 | Abby Rush Boston University |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Roger Peterkin PENN | 11-2 | Matt Pagan NAVY |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 7-4 | Clint Frutiger MSU |
| Christian Smith Unattached | 11-0 | Jeff Oldham MD |
| Abby Rush Boston University | PIN 1:12 | George Ester Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Mark McKnight PSU | 7-4 | Fernando Martinez ARMY |
| James Nicholson Unattached | 3-2 | Matt Fisk Unattached |
| Brad Pataky Unattached | 12-3 | Alex Usztics NAVY |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 5-2 | Derrek Bosso PITT-J |
| Abby Rush Boston University | 3-1 | Adam Shemon NAVY |
| Clint Frutiger MSU | 8-6 | Scott Morgan PITT-J |
| George Ester Unattached | 8-5 | Nick Hyatt LHU |
| Jeff Oldham MD | 6-2 | Jerome Greco COLU |
| Roger Peterkin PENN | 5-0 | Zack Fraley PITT |
| Matt Pagan NAVY | 12-7 | Sheridan Moran VT |
| Christian Smith Unattached | 6-5 | Jason Guffey Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Sheridan Moran VT | 15-4 | Brett Skonieczny Unattached |
| Jason Guffey Unattached | 4-2 | Toby Seger CLAR |
| Zack Fraley PITT | MED. FORFEIT | Jim Porch Unattached |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 17-3 | Corey Sullivan BING |
| Nick Hyatt LHU | 5-3 | Michael Watts Unattached |
| Jerome Greco COLU | 7-4 | John Andel MVILLE |
| Adam Shemon NAVY | PIN 0:56 | Cory Weiss Kutztown University |
| Scott Morgan PITT-J | 5-2 | Lou Ruland Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| James Nicholson Unattached | PIN 3:57 | Josh Statum Boston University |
| Fernando Martinez ARMY | 9-3 | Christian Smith Unattached |
| Matt Fisk Unattached | 12-0 | Derrek Bosso PITT-J |
| Mark McKnight PSU | 14-5 | Jeff Oldham MD |
| Obenson Blanc LHU | 9-8 | Roger Peterkin PENN |
| Alex Usztics NAVY | 18-3 | Abby Rush Boston University |
| Brad Pataky Unattached | PIN 0:17 | George Ester Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Christian Smith Unattached | 2-1 | Adam Shemon NAVY |
| Alex Usztics NAVY | 14-6 | Jason Guffey Unattached |
| James Nicholson Unattached | 10-0 | Brett Skonieczny Unattached |
| Clint Frutiger MSU | 7-2 | Sheridan Moran VT |
| Matt Fisk Unattached | PIN 1:06 | Zack Fraley PITT |
| Brad Pataky Unattached | PIN 0:39 | Jerome Greco COLU |
| George Ester Unattached | 7-5 | John Andel MVILLE |
| Abby Rush Boston University | 5-2 | Toby Seger CLAR |
| Jeff Oldham MD | 5-4 | Michael Watts Unattached |
| Fernando Martinez |
| Round of 64 |
| Fernando Martinez ARMY | PIN 6:25 | Pat McCaffrey Unattached |
| Christian Smith Unattached | 7-0 | Greg Sill Unattached |
| Michael Watts Unattached | PIN 4:58 | Ian Moser Unattached |
| Jim Porch Unattached | 3-0 | Michael Acedo-Malaney MVILLE |
| Lou Ruland Unattached | 7-1 | Eric Caschera Unattached |
| Jerome Greco COLU | 4-3 | Wesley Fike Unattached |
| Adam Shemon NAVY | 3-1 | Mike Keenan BING |
| Jeff Oldham MD | 5-3 | Adam Hohman Unattached |
| Obenson Blanc LHU | 3-2 | Ryan Riggs Cleveland State University |
|
