| Finals |
| Ben Wissel Independent1st | DEC 7-4 | Joe Williams MSU2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Jake Varner ISU3rd | DEC 4-2 | Christian Sinnott CMU4th |
| Louis Caputo HARV5th | DEC 3-1 | John Dergo ILL6th |
| Marc Bennett IND7th | FORFEIT | Gerald Harris Independent8th |
| Consolation |
| Duke Burk NIU | DEC 8-4 | Cary Aldrich COLU |
| Vince Jones Independent | PIN 5:38 | Charlie Pienaar EMU |
| Louis Caputo HARV | DEC 7-6 | Gerald Harris Independent |
| Eric Simaz CMU | DEC 7-6 | Terrence Madden Independent |
| Gerald Harris Independent | DEC 5-3 | Danny Dunning UNI |
| Christian Sinnott CMU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | John Dergo ILL |
| Danny Dunning UNI | DEC 6-2 | David Gleissner ILL |
| Gerald Harris Independent | DEC 8-4 | Vince Jones Independent |
| Chris Gibbs West Liberty University | DEC 7-3 | Tony Gehling Upper Iowa |
| Andrew Silber SHU | PIN 2:53 | Chris Gibbs West Liberty University |
| Gerald Harris Independent | DEC 7-3 | David Gilkey Cleveland State University |
| Greg Perz EIU | DEFAULT | Scott Hazen UNI |
| Duke Burk NIU | DEC 10-6 | Greg Perz EIU |
| Chris Gibbs West Liberty University | PIN 5:17 | Anthony Fuschino AU |
| Greg Perz EIU | FORFEIT | Chance Litton WVU |
| Jake Varner ISU | DEC 5-3 | Louis Caputo HARV |
| Charlie Pienaar EMU | MAJ DEC 13-0 | Evan Murtaugh AU |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | DEC | Dallas Mitchell UNI |
| Louis Caputo HARV | DEC 1-0 | Duke Burk NIU |
| Will Clarke Wabash College | DEC 4-3 | Dwayne Hash AU |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Daron Cruickshank Olivet College |
| Charlie Pienaar EMU | DEC 4-2 | Jacob Devlin AF |
| Dallas Mitchell UNI | DEC 8-2 | Jason Lulloff Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| John Dergo ILL | DEC 6-3 | Marc Bennett IND |
| Dallas Mitchell UNI | DEC 8-3 | Nick Skinner PUR |
| Andrew Silber SHU | DEC 6-3 | Mike Miller RIDER |
| Duke Burk NIU | PIN 3:31 | Phil Bruschuk Upper Iowa |
| Marc Bennett IND | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Andrew Silber SHU |
| Terrence Madden Independent | DEC 7-5 | Phillip Keddy IOWA |
| Mike Miller RIDER | DEC 5-3 | Eric Simaz CMU |
| John Dergo ILL | DEC 4-2 | Colin Hitschler PENN |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | DEC 3-0 | Will Clarke Wabash College |
| Duke Burk NIU | DEC 5-1 | Rick Loera IOWA |
| Semifinal |
| Ben Wissel Independent | DEC 4-1 | Christian Sinnott CMU |
| Joe Williams MSU | DEC 3-1 | Jake Varner ISU |
| Quarterfinal |
| Joe Williams MSU | DEC 9-3 | John Dergo ILL |
| Jake Varner ISU | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Marc Bennett IND |
| Christian Sinnott CMU | DEC 7-4 | Louis Caputo HARV |
| Ben Wissel Independent | TF 16-0 | David Gilkey Cleveland State University |
| Round of 16 |
| Louis Caputo HARV | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Mike Miller RIDER |
| Marc Bennett IND | DEC 6-2 | Rick Loera IOWA |
| Joe Williams MSU | TF 19-4 | Vince Jones Independent |
| John Dergo ILL | DEC 6-4 | Gerald Harris Independent |
| Christian Sinnott CMU | DEC 9-4 | Andrew Silber SHU |
| Jake Varner ISU | PIN 2:10 | Chance Litton WVU |
| Ben Wissel Independent | TF 17-0 | Daron Cruickshank Olivet College |
| David Gilkey Cleveland State University | PIN 6:39 | Jason Lulloff Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Round of 32 |
| Jake Varner ISU | PIN 5:28 | Nick Skinner PUR |
| John Dergo ILL | DEC 8-5 | Eric Simaz CMU |
| Gerald Harris Independent | DEC 6-5 | Terrence Madden Independent |
| Ben Wissel Independent | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Duke Burk NIU |
| Daron Cruickshank Olivet College | DEC 9-7 | Phil Bruschuk Upper Iowa |
| Mike Miller RIDER | DEC 3-2 | Danny Dunning UNI |
| Marc Bennett IND | DEC 4-2 | Colin Hitschler PENN |
| Louis Caputo HARV | DEC 7-1 | David Gleissner ILL |
| Chance Litton WVU | DEC 6-1 | Dallas Mitchell UNI |
| David Gilkey |
| Round of 64 |
| Duke Burk NIU | DEC 5-2 | Phillip Keddy IOWA |
| Terrence Madden Independent | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Cary Aldrich COLU |
| Jason Lulloff Wisconsin-La Crosse | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Chris Gibbs West Liberty University |
| Nick Skinner PUR | DEC 4-2 | Charlie Pienaar EMU |
| Mike Miller RIDER | DEC 7-3 | Will Clarke Wabash College |
