| Finals |
| Mike Poeta ILL1st | DEC 9-8 | Trent Paulson ISU2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Moza Fay UNI3rd | DEC 9-5 | Andrew Flanagan HARV4th |
| Jason Knipp ISU5th | DEC 5-1 | Brian Cobb6th |
| Ryan Morningstar IOWA7th | DEC 4-2 | Colby Goetsch UNI8th |
| Consolation |
| Rob Morrison RIDER | PIN 3:22 | Jimmy Peppers AU |
| Colby Goetsch UNI | DEC 9-3 | Kalen Knull NIU |
| Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University | PIN 3:23 | Kyle Katz Elmhurst University |
| Colby Goetsch UNI | FORFEIT | Brandon Becker IND |
| Joe Rujawitz SIUE | DEC 6-4 | Ryan Pribble IND |
| Jason Brew Olivet College | DEC 3-1 | Joe Rujawitz SIUE |
| Dallas Hesseltine Harper College | DEC 5-3 | Clint Arlis ILL |
| Tony Greathouse MSU | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Brad Medchill IOWA |
| Kalen Knull NIU | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Kile O'Toole EIU |
| Tony Greathouse MSU | DEC 7-2 | Elliott Spence Mount St. Joseph |
| Rob Morrison RIDER | DEC 10-8 | Zach Lord AF |
| Colby Goetsch UNI | DEC 6-4 | Kenneth Packard San Francisco State University |
| Jason Knipp ISU | DEC 4-2 | Colby Goetsch UNI |
| Dallas Hesseltine Harper College | DEC 4-1 | Yevgeniy Savenok Wheaton College |
| Jason Brew Olivet College | DEC 11-4 | Rob Morrison RIDER |
| Brian Cobb | DEC 4-3 | Ryan Morningstar IOWA |
| Elliott Spence Mount St. Joseph | DEC 4-2 | Chris Kelly MacMurray College |
| Jason Knipp ISU | DEC 4-3 | Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University |
| Eric Howe PUR | DEC 7-5 | Matthew Button HARV |
| Brad Medchill IOWA | DEC 3-2 | Dallas Hesseltine Harper College |
| Moza Fay UNI | PIN 4:38 | Brian Cobb |
| Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University | DEC 9-7 | Roberto Vargus |
| Joe Rujawitz SIUE | FORFEIT | Andy Keller CMU |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | DEC 5-0 | Jason Knipp ISU |
| Kenneth Packard San Francisco State University | DEC 8-6 | Tyler Reiner UNI |
| Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University | DEC 8-5 | Eric Howe PUR |
| Eric Howe PUR | DEC 3-1 | Rex Kendle MSU |
| Brian Cobb | DEC 3-1 | Jason Brew Olivet College |
| Roberto Vargus | DEC 6-2 | Ken Andrews Olivet College |
| Kalen Knull NIU | DEC 3-1 | Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Ryan Morningstar IOWA | DEC 3-1 | Tony Greathouse MSU |
| Semifinal |
| Trent Paulson ISU | PIN 5:53 | Andrew Flanagan HARV |
| Mike Poeta ILL | DEC 8-3 | Moza Fay UNI |
| Quarterfinal |
| Trent Paulson ISU | MAJ DEC 17-8 | Brian Cobb |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | DEC 5-0 | Ryan Morningstar IOWA |
| Mike Poeta ILL | DEC 8-3 | Jason Knipp ISU |
| Moza Fay UNI | DEFAULT | Brandon Becker IND |
| Round of 16 |
| Moza Fay UNI | DEC 13-7 | Jason Brew Olivet College |
| Ryan Morningstar IOWA | DEC 8-6 | Kyle Katz Elmhurst University |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Rex Kendle MSU |
| Jason Knipp ISU | DEC 2-0 | Tony Greathouse MSU |
| Mike Poeta ILL | MAJ DEC 17-4 | Brad Medchill IOWA |
| Brandon Becker IND | DEFAULT | Andy Keller CMU |
| Trent Paulson ISU | PIN 0:36 | Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Brian Cobb | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Colby Goetsch UNI |
| Round of 32 |
| Rex Kendle MSU | DEC 5-1 | Zach Lord AF |
| Brandon Becker IND | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University |
| Kyle Katz Elmhurst University | DEC 10-4 | Ryan Pribble IND |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | TF 17-2 | Jimmy Peppers AU |
| Ryan Morningstar IOWA | DEC 5-0 | Joe Rujawitz SIUE |
| Colby Goetsch UNI | DEC 6-5 | Dallas Hesseltine Harper College |
| Brad Medchill IOWA | PIN 4:50 | Tyler Reiner UNI |
| Andy Keller CMU | DEC 3-1 | Roberto Vargus |
| Moza Fay UNI | DEC 9-2 | Eric Howe PUR |
| Ross Needham |
| Round of 64 |
| Brad Medchill IOWA | DEC 5-3 | Rob Morrison RIDER |
| Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse | PIN 3:49 | Ken Andrews Olivet College |
| Matthew Button HARV | DEC 4-0 | Yevgeniy Savenok Wheaton College |
