| Finals |
| Derek Moore UCD1st | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Dominick Moyer NEB2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS3rd | — | Dave Roberts POLY4th |
| Michael Keefe CHAT5th | MAJ DEC 17-4 | Chris Bencivenga UNCG6th |
| Charles Griffin HOF7th | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Kyle Larson ORST8th |
| Consi Semi |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 8-4 | Ryan Flores ORST |
| Semifinal |
| Dominick Moyer NEB | PIN 1:40 | Chris Bencivenga UNCG |
| Derek Moore UCD | PIN 4:06 | Dave Roberts POLY |
| Consi 4 |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 5-2 | Matt Schumm CSUB |
| Ryan Flores ORST | DEC 10-6 | Jeffery Jaggers OSU |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | PIN 2:28 | Joey Deaguero Adams State |
| Jeffery Jaggers OSU | MAJ DEC 16-6 | Heinrich Barnes North Idaho College |
| Quarterfinal |
| Chris Bencivenga UNCG | DEC 11-10 | Michael Keefe CHAT |
| Dominick Moyer NEB | DEC 5-4 | Charles Griffin HOF |
| Dave Roberts POLY | DEC 5-2 | Matt Schumm CSUB |
| Derek Moore UCD | DEC 11-7 | Ryan Flores ORST |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 9-4 | Corey Manson COR |
| Joey Deaguero Adams State | DEC 3-1 | Stephen DeLorenzo BRWN |
| Heinrich Barnes North Idaho College | DEC 2-0 | Kellon Balum UVA |
| Jeffery Jaggers OSU | DEC 6-2 | Rick Rappo PENN |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Corey Manson COR | PIN 0:43 | Brad Cusumano MICH |
| Stephen DeLorenzo BRWN | DEC 2-1 | Bennie Garcia Justin Morrill |
| Heinrich Barnes North Idaho College | DEC 7-2 | Chris Freije Western Colorado University |
| Jeffery Jaggers OSU | DEC 4-1 | Clint Sponseller KENT |
| Round of 16 |
| Chris Bencivenga UNCG | DEC 10-8 | Kellon Balum UVA |
| Michael Keefe CHAT | DEC 4-2 | Rick Rappo PENN |
| Dominick Moyer NEB | DEC 9-3 | Kyle Ruschell WIS |
| Charles Griffin HOF | DEC 5-2 | Joey Deaguero Adams State |
| Matt Schumm CSUB | DEC 3-0 | Gordo Villaescusa Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
| Dave Roberts POLY | — | Pat Payne ASU |
| Ryan Flores ORST | DEC 6-1 | Jake Kriegbaum AF |
| Derek Moore UCD | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Rafael Chavez STAN |
| Consi 16 #1 |
| Brad Cusumano MICH | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Jeff Rutledge Zach Donofrio |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | PIN 2:44 | Chris Bencivenga UNCG |
| Bennie Garcia Justin Morrill | DEC 7-4 | Jeff Rutledge Zach Donofrio |
| Stephen DeLorenzo BRWN | DEC 3-1 | Bennie Garcia Justin Morrill |
| Heinrich Barnes North Idaho College | DEC 7-3 | Jeffrey Newby BSU |
| Chris Freije Western Colorado University | DEC 10-4 | Stuart Brinkman Western Wyoming Community College |
| Clint Sponseller KENT | DEC 7-5 | Justin Metcalfe NIU |
| Jake Kriegbaum AF | MAJ DEC 13-1 | Joe Ciampoli PITT |
| Michael Arias CIT | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Andrew Stella |
| Round of 32 |
| Chris Bencivenga UNCG | DEC 5-2 | Brandon Rader WVU |
| Kellon Balum UVA | DEC 7-1 | Garrett Desmond WYO |
| Rick Rappo PENN | PIN 4:40 | Don Fisch RIDER |
| Michael Keefe CHAT | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Virgil Lockett San Francisco State University |
| Dominick Moyer NEB | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Nick Walpole IND |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Albert Madsen OHIO |
| Joey Deaguero Adams State | DEC 9-4 | Joe Ciampoli PITT |
| Charles Griffin HOF | DEC 8-2 | Andrew Stella Buffalo Wrestling Club |
| Matt Schumm CSUB | DEC 7-4 | Jeffery Jaggers OSU |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Kellon Balum UVA | DEC 7-1 | Brad Cusumano MICH |
| Don Fisch RIDER | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Zach Donofrio EMU |
| Michael Keefe CHAT | DEC 10-5 | Justin Morrill UVU |
| Dominick Moyer NEB | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Heinrich Barnes North Idaho College |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 3-2 | Chris Freije Western Colorado University |
| Joey Deaguero Adams State | DEC 9-8 | Clint Sponseller KENT |
| Matt Schumm CSUB | TF 16-1 | Michael Arias CIT |
| Jeffrey Newby BSU | DEC 6-4 | Derek Francavilla COLU |
| Stephen DeLorenzo BRWN | DEC 5-1 | Amond Prater MIZZ |
|
