| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Ben Askren MIZZ1st | ||
| TF 25-10 |
| Donny Reynolds ILL2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Kenny Robertson EIU3rd | DEC 1-0 | Eric Ring EDIN4th |
| Matt Winterhalter ILL5th | DEC 1-0 | Mike Kelly Unattached6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Eric Ring EDIN | DEC 3-1 | Mike Kelly Unattached |
| Kenny Robertson EIU | DEC 5-3 | Matt Winterhalter ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Ben Askren MIZZ | PIN 3:25 | Eric Ring EDIN |
| Donny Reynolds ILL | DEC 7-5 | Kenny Robertson EIU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Mike Kelly Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Eric Scholle Unattached |
| Matt Winterhalter ILL | MAJ DEC 16-3 | Marc Bennett IND |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Mike Kelly Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Eric Crow Unattached |
| Eric Scholle Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Trevor Perry Unattached |
| Marc Bennett IND | PIN 2:43 | Sean McAleney Unattached |
| Matt Winterhalter ILL | DEC 6-1 | Joey Garrity MIZZ |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ben Askren MIZZ | PIN 1:57 | Matt Winterhalter ILL |
| Eric Ring EDIN | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Sean McAleney Unattached |
| Donny Reynolds ILL | DEC 10-3 | Eric Scholle Unattached |
| Kenny Robertson EIU | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Eric Crow Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Mike Kelly Unattached | TF 15-0 | Shawn Crow Unattached |
| Trevor Perry Unattached | TF 20-5 | O'Sung Kim OKLA |
| Marc Bennett IND | DEC 3-1 | Josh Johnston Missouri Valley College |
| Joey Garrity MIZZ | DEFAULT | Josh Decker Unattached |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Ben Askren MIZZ | PIN 2:21 | Mike Kelly Unattached |
| Matt Winterhalter ILL | PIN 3:25 | Shawn Crow Unattached |
| Sean McAleney Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Trevor Perry Unattached |
| Eric Ring EDIN | DEC 8-2 | O'Sung Kim OKLA |
| Donny Reynolds ILL | DEC 9-2 | Marc Bennett IND |
| Eric Scholle Unattached | DEC 3-1 | Josh Johnston Missouri Valley College |
| Eric Crow Unattached | DEFAULT | Josh Decker Unattached |
| Kenny Robertson EIU | PIN 3:25 | Joey Garrity MIZZ |