| Matt Pell MIZZ | PIN 0:48 | Omari Johnson Unattached |
| Mitch Casto Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Kevin Knabjian EIU |
| Deonte Penn EDIN | PIN 0:34 | Clay Weir McKendree University |
| Nelson Gosnel ODU | PIN 4:36 | Jake Jackson OKLA |
| Jarrod King OKLA | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Justin Cooper UCM |
| Keegan Mueller Unattached | DEC 12-7 | Daniel Chionuma Lindenwood University |
| Drew Dickerson Unattached | PIN 0:40 | Andrew Tsensee Unattached |
| John Lowery Unattached | DEC 7-2 | Max Dean IND |