| Gregor Gillespie EDIN | TF 17-1 | Andrew Sherry MIZZ |
| Jim Comfort ILL | DEC 7-5 | Christopher Smith EIU |
| Aaron Martin Unattached | DEC 5-0 | Randy Vanderveen Lindenwood University |
| Chris Seta Campbellsville University | DEC 7-2 | Matt Wagemann Unattached |
| Matt Cooper IND | DEC 5-4 | Troy Tirapelle ILL |
| Jed Lewis MIZZ | DEC 7-5 | Adam Beeler Unattached |
| Josh Blackburn McKendree University | DEC 3-2 | Justin Cole MIZZ |
| Will Rowe OKLA | DEC 7-4 | Danny Zeman Unattached |