| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Chad Weber Unattached | PIN 3:51 | Ryan Propst Harper College |
| Keaton Baker UCM | PIN 5:03 | Justin Talley Campbellsville University |
| Chuck Patten Unattached | PIN 0:52 | Antoney Rienzi Unattached |
| JJ Anderson Unattached | DEC 7-0 | Kaci Payne Campbellsville University |
| Jon Gerhold Missouri Valley College | DEC 10-3 | Paul Njoku Unattached |
| Scott Kruk Unattached | PIN 3:17 | Ian McGill McKendree University |
| Robbie Grose McKendree University | DEC 8-6 | Mike Ryan Harper College |
| Ryan Morgan EDIN | DEC 6-0 | Dan Keller Unattached |
| Brian Lange Harper College | DEC 6-4 | Scott Kelly IND |
| Tony Forte SIUE | PIN 1:37 | Derek Fannin Wentworth Military Academy |
| Nathan Kleckler Unattached | DEC 5-2 | Brian Gaskill Missouri Valley College |