| Finals |
| Alex Tirapelle ILL1st | DEC 3-0 | Joe Johnston IOWA2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Matt Lebe WVU3rd | PIN 5:18 | Zac Fryling Unattached4th |
| Matt Kocher Unattached5th | DEC 4-2 | Brandon Becker IND6th |
| Andy Keller CMU7th | DEC 6-4 | Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached8th |
| Consi Semi |
| Zac Fryling Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Andy Keller CMU |
| Matt Kocher Unattached | DEC 13-7 | Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Alex Tirapelle ILL | DEC 3-1 | Matt Lebe WVU |
| Joe Johnston IOWA | DEC 8-5 | Brandon Becker IND |
| Consi 4 |
| Zac Fryling Unattached | DEC 8-5 | Greg Hagel NW |
| Andy Keller CMU | DEC 3-1 | Chris Bitetto UNI |
| Matt Kocher Unattached | DEC 7-3 | Moza Fay UNI |
| Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Devin Mesanko Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Greg Hagel NW | DEC 6-3 | Sherwood Fendryk SHU |
| Andy Keller CMU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Moza Fay UNI | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Matt Collum Ia Cent |
| Devin Mesanko Unattached | DEC 7-5 | Travis Picard Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Alex Tirapelle ILL | DEC 2-1 | Matt Kocher Unattached |
| Matt Lebe WVU | DEC 5-5 | Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached |
| Brandon Becker IND | DEC 2-0 | Zac Fryling Unattached |
| Joe Johnston IOWA | DEC 11-5 | Chris Bitetto UNI |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Greg Hagel NW | DEC 6-0 | Yevgeniy Savenok Wheaton |
| Sherwood Fendryk SHU | PIN 3:38 | Ken Andrews Olivet College |
| Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse | DEC 2-1 | Kalen Knull NIU |
| Andy Keller CMU | DEC 5-3 | Andrew Flanagan HARV |
| Moza Fay UNI | TF 15-0 | Travis Koppenhafer Unattached |
| Matt Collum Ia Cent | DEC 12-7 | Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University |
| Travis Picard Unattached | DEC 8-2 | Kirk Fitzpatrick San Francisco State University |
| Devin Mesanko Unattached | FORFEIT | — |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Yevgeniy Savenok Wheaton | DEC 7-0 | Tade Kemnitz Wild WC |
| Sherwood Fendryk SHU | PIN 3:48 | Casey Roddis MacMurray College |
| Kalen Knull NIU | DEC 2-1 | Bobby Gingerich North Central College |
| Andy Keller CMU | DEC 3-1 | Emanuel Brooks Unattached |
| Moza Fay UNI | MAJ DEC 15-2 | Brad Medchill IOWA |
| Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Jake Murphy PUR |
| Travis Picard Unattached | PIN 2:32 | Spencer Burns University of Chicago |
| Devin Mesanko Unattached | DEC 7-2 | Aaron Owen NIU |
| Round of 16 |
| Alex Tirapelle ILL | DEC 5-3 | Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Matt Kocher Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Andrew Flanagan HARV |
| Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached | TF 19-4 | Greg Hagel NW |
| Matt Lebe WVU | DEC 2-0 | Ken Andrews Olivet College |
| Brandon Becker IND | DEC 4-0 | Kirk Fitzpatrick San Francisco State University |
| Zac Fryling Unattached | DEFAULT | Tony Greathouse MSU |
| Chris Bitetto UNI | DEC 4-3 | Travis Koppenhafer Unattached |
| Joe Johnston IOWA | MAJ DEC 20-9 | Matt Collum Ia Cent |
| Consi 16 #1 |
| Sherwood Fendryk SHU | DEC 5-1 | Scott Loescher STAN |
| Round of 32 |
| Alex Tirapelle ILL | DEC 2-0 | Devin Mesanko Unattached |
| Ross Needham Wisconsin-La Crosse | DEC 3-2 | Aaron Owen NIU |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | PIN 5:24 | Travis Picard Unattached |
| Matt Kocher Unattached | PIN 0:59 | Spencer Burns University of Chicago |
| Jeremiah Jarvis Unattached | PIN 4:32 | Victer Crenshaw Cleveland State University |
| Greg Hagel NW | DEC 4-2 | Jake Murphy PUR |
| Ken Andrews Olivet College | PIN 4:24 | Brad Medchill IOWA |
| Matt Lebe WVU | DEC 6-4 | Moza Fay UNI |
| Brandon Becker IND | PIN 4:45 | Andy Keller CMU |
| Round of 64 |
| Andrew Flanagan HARV | DEC 3-1 | Sherwood Fendryk SHU |
