| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Mike Roberts Boston University | DEC 12-6 | Brandon Doyle CSUB |
| Derek Coorough IOWA | DEC 10-9 | Ryan Hurley Cleveland State University |
| Troy Tirapelle ILL | PIN 2:51 | Thomas Johnson EIU |
| Bobby Latessa HARV | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Eddo Hojilla UNCP |
| Chris Seta Campsville | DEC 2-0 | Brett Stedman IOWA |
| Rob Hitschler PENN | PIN 1:56 | Alex Grunder IOWA |
| Colby Goetsch UNI | DEC 7-4 | Jake Larsen Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Jeff Tharp EIU | DEC 13-6 | Rob Jacobson Wheaton |