| Pat DeGain IND | PIN 2:06 | Ben Connell UNC |
| Renwick Richardson Unattached | DEC 7-4 | Jake O'Brien PUR |
| Joel Tapler OKLA | DEC 5-1 | Bryan Morgan Millikin University |
| Peter Ziminski Unattached | PIN 0:41 | Chris Johnson Missouri Valley College |
| Roger Miller Lindenwood University | DEC 3-2 | Spencer Nadolsky UNC |
| Chris Little ILL | DEC 3-1 | Sam Kirkland Unattached |
| Dave Herman IND | PIN 3:13 | Dan Perez Unattached |
| Jake Hager OKLA | PIN 0:53 | Adam Nuru Missouri Valley College |