| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Vito Barbagallo Lindenwood University | DEFAULT | Matt Grogan McKendree University |
| Mark Powell Unattached | DEC 4-3 | Chad Swagman Truman State University |
| Ryan William Unattached | DEC 5-0 | Ben Strake Lindenwood University |
| Randy Vanderveen Lindenwood University | DEC 4-3 | Ryan Pribble Unattached |
| Troy Tirapelle Unattached | DEC 8-5 | Josh Blackburn McKendree University |
| Nick Newton Unattached | DEC 7-6 | Jamie Williams Lindenwood University |
| Justin Edwards Millikin University | DEC 3-2 | Jason Oberman Unattached |
| Shane Dintelman EIU | DEC 7-2 | Joe Drake UCM |