| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Matt Gentry STAN | TF 16-0 | Jaime Alvarez San Francisco State University |
| Paul Bjorlo UVA | DEC 4-1 | Brock Wittmeyer PENN |
| Brian Cobb Dave Schultz WC | DEC 10-3 | Chad Roush EMU |
| Jeremiah Jarvis Dave Schultz WC | PIN 2:57 | Brian Busby CSUB |
| Luke Main West Liberty University | DEFAULT | John Vogel OSU |
| Alex Fliaha Lassen College | DEC 11-6 | Aaron Owen NIU |
| Ryan LeBeau Luther College | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Todd Kennitz Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| Scott Owen New York Athletic Club | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Rick Lamas Elmhurst University |
| Muzaffar Abdurakhmanov AU | MAJ DEC 15-6 | Gene Zannetti RU |
| Devin Mesanko COLU | DEC 7-0 | Andy Mangaiguera EIU |
| Mike Parziale FM | DEC 10-6 | Aaron Gunning UNCP |
| Matt Lebe WVU | PIN 2:43 | Chris Bitello UNI |
| Marcus Effner Cleveland State University | PIN 3:08 | Justin Mora MSU |
| Oleg Polyatskij IOWA | DEC 9-7 | Scott Cleve Adams State |
| Brandon Becker IND | PIN 1:42 | Alex Nelson NIU |