| Rapheal Davis Unattached1st | DEC 3-1 | Leonce Crump OKLA2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Willie Gruenwald OKST3rd | DEC 10-6 | Jake Hager OKLA4th |
| Mike Whitehead Unattached5th | DEC 3-1 | Peter Ziminski EIU6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Jake Hager OKLA | DEC 3-2 | Peter Ziminski EIU |
| Willie Gruenwald OKST | DEC 5-4 | Mike Whitehead Unattached |
| Semifinal | ||
| Leonce Crump OKLA | DEC 8-3 | Mike Whitehead Unattached |
| Rapheal Davis Unattached | DEC 5-1 | Jake Hager OKLA |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Peter Ziminski EIU | FORFEIT | Tony Vaughn Unattached |
| Willie Gruenwald OKST | DEC 3-2 | Cain Velasquez ASU |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Peter Ziminski EIU | DEC 6-5 | Clifford Starks ASU |
| Tony Vaughn Unattached | DEC 3-1 | Ryan Adams UNC |
| Cain Velasquez ASU | DEC 4-3 | Mike Behnke ILL |
| Willie Gruenwald OKST | DEC 11-4 | Matt Fletcher ILL |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Leonce Crump OKLA | DEC 5-2 | Tony Vaughn Unattached |
| Mike Whitehead Unattached | DEC 2-0 | Clifford Starks ASU |
| Rapheal Davis Unattached | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Willie Gruenwald OKST |
| Jake Hager OKLA | DEC 5-3 | Cain Velasquez ASU |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Peter Ziminski EIU | DEC 3-1 | Chris Little ILL |
| Ryan Adams UNC | FORFEIT | Bryan Jourick Unattached |
| Mike Behnke ILL | DEC 7-4 | Marco Hernandez Unattached |
| Matt Fletcher ILL | DEC 3-0 | Gilbert Jones Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Peter Ziminski EIU | DEC 3-1 | Drew Phillips Unattached |
| Chris Little ILL | FORFEIT | Zak Jensen NIU |
| Ryan Adams UNC | DEC 5-2 | Willie McCowan UCM |
| Marco Hernandez Unattached | PIN 2:38 | Kyle Wellington Unattached |
| Matt Fletcher ILL | DEC 4-2 | Jason Pennington CHAT |
| Gilbert Jones Unattached | PIN 2:47 | John Vestal OKST |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Leonce Crump OKLA | DEC 1-0 | John Vestal OKST |
| Tony Vaughn Unattached | PIN 5:55 | Matt Fletcher ILL |
| Clifford Starks ASU | DEC 3-1 | Mike Behnke ILL |
| Mike Whitehead Unattached | PIN 2:56 | Kyle Wellington Unattached |
| Willie Gruenwald OKST | DEC 8-7 | Willie McCowan UCM |
| Rapheal Davis Unattached | PIN 3:08 | Bryan Jourick Unattached |
| Jake Hager OKLA | DEC 2-1 | Chris Little ILL |
| Cain Velasquez ASU | DEC 5-2 | Peter Ziminski EIU |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Leonce Crump OKLA | PIN 5:22 | Drew Phillips Unattached |
| Tony Vaughn Unattached | DEC 4-2 | Zak Jensen NIU |
| Mike Whitehead Unattached | DEC 2-1 | Ryan Adams UNC |
| Willie Gruenwald OKST | PIN 1:24 | Marco Hernandez Unattached |
| Chris Little ILL | DEC 9-4 | Jason Pennington CHAT |
| Peter Ziminski EIU | DEC 3-0 | Gilbert Jones Unattached |