| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Brain Schoenherr McKendree University | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Trint Mathews Unattached |
| Sam Kirkland University of the Cumberlands | DEFAULT | Michael Paxton Lindenwood University |
| Joe Sapp Unattached | DEC 11-6 | Dave Herman Unattached |
| Chris Johnson Unattached | PIN 1:03 | Justin Lash McKendree University |
| Wes Taylor Unattached | DEC 9-5 | Mark Root McKendree University |
| Jake O'Brien Unattached | DEC 10-3 | Murphy Mahalik Unattached |
| Tanner Munsell Unattached | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Zack Mantle EIU |
| Terry King Unattached | DEC 3-1 | John Roberts Lindenwood University |