| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consolation |
| Stipe Miocic Cleveland State University | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Sean Barnes University of Chicago |
| Jason Lovell ORST | DEC 5-4 | Venroy July UNC |
| Pat DeGain IND | PIN 2:43 | Andy Bollhoefer PENN |
| Pat DeGain IND | PIN 5:32 | Stipe Miocic Cleveland State University |
| Erik Gladish ASU | DEC 6-5 | Ryan Fulsaas IOWA |
| Jim Kassner EIU | DEC 1-0 | Jack Dennis NIU |
| Jim Kassner EIU | DEC 5-4 | Trey Clark IOWA |
| Ryan Fulsaas IOWA | DEC 7-5 | Mike Bigrigg NAVY |
| Nick Preston OSU | DEC 3-1 | Matt Greenberg COR |
| Owen Elzen MINN | DEC 1-1 | Nick Preston OSU |
| Matt Greenberg COR | DEC 2-1 | Mike Faust PENN |
| Bill Stouffer CMU | PIN 5:27 | Nick Curby ILL |
| Chris Skretkowicz HOF | PIN 1:35 | Pat DeGain IND |
| Jon Trenge LEH | DEC 2-1 | Emmett Willson Montana State - Northern |
| Mike Bigrigg NAVY | DEC 9-5 | Greg Sawyer RIDER |
| Brendan Curran NW | DEC 7-6 | Brian Toney VMI |
| Jason Lovell ORST | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Robert Odell CSUB |
| Andy Bollhoefer PENN | DEC 6-4 | Josh Lepper Lincoln College |
| Stipe Miocic Cleveland State University | DEC 6-4 | Jason Vincens ILL |
| Matt Greenberg COR | DEC 10-4 | Jim Kassner EIU |
| Emmett Willson Montana State - Northern | DEC 5-1 | Ty Matthews IND |
| Emmett Willson Montana State - Northern | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Brendan Curran NW |
| Ryan Fulsaas IOWA | DEC 6-2 | Bill Stouffer CMU |
| Emmett Willson Montana State - Northern | DEC 4-2 | Jason Lovell ORST |
| Nick Preston OSU | DEC 6-3 | Chris Skretkowicz HOF |
| Emmett Willson Montana State - Northern | DEC 10-4 | Erik Gladish ASU |