| Finals |
| Alexis Vila Unattached1st | DEC 6-5 | Leroy Vega MINN2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Mike Simpson ASU3rd | DEC 12-6 | Ty Malia ISU4th |
| Luke Eustice IOWA5th | DEC 6-3 | Mason Lenhard PENN6th |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J7th | DEC 6-2 | Chris Williams MSU8th |
| Consolation |
| Mike Mormile COR | PIN 4:43 | Brandon Murphy EIU |
| Michael Delaney ORST | DEC 4-1 | Robert Potashnick NW |
| Tom Combes Wildcat Wrestling Club | PIN 3:08 | Dan Pacitti UNCG |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J | DEC 3-0 | Michael Delaney ORST |
| Mike Simpson ASU | DEC 5-3 | Brandon Newill PITT-J |
| Adam Mars Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Vic Moreno CSUB |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Nick Kehagias University of Chicago |
| Jerold Limongelli RIDER | DEC 6-1 | Nathan Peterson STAN |
| Tom Combes Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 16-11 | Jerold Limongelli RIDER |
| Ty Malia ISU | DEC 6-4 | Chris Williams MSU |
| Dan Pacitti UNCG | DEC 3-1 | Tony Stewart UNCG |
| Nathan Peterson STAN | DEC 7-2 | Craig Trombly MSU |
| Chris Rodrigues UNC | DEC 8-5 | Jesse Leng OSU |
| Jason Borrelli CMU | PIN 3:46 | Adam Mars Unattached |
| Mike Simpson ASU | DEFAULT | Tom Combes Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| Vic Moreno CSUB | DEC 3-1 | Terrance Clendenin Unattached |
| Chris Rodrigues UNC | DEC 7-3 | Justin McClintock Iowa Central Community College |
| Adam Mars Unattached | DEC 7-4 | Rocco Mansueto Cleveland State University |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J | DEC 1-0 | Erkin Tadzhimetov UCM |
| Ty Malia ISU | DEC 12-5 | Jason Borrelli CMU |
| Ty Malia ISU | DEC 6-5 | Luke Eustice IOWA |
| Matt Shankey IOWA | PIN 0:35 | Andy Gleixner MacMurray College |
| Matt Shankey IOWA | PIN 2:24 | Michel Moharreri Lincoln College |
| Jason Borrelli CMU | DEC 12-6 | Mike Mormile COR |
| Michael Delaney ORST | FORFEIT | Greg Schaefer IND |
| Chris Williams MSU | DEC 1-0 | Twan Pham ILL |
| Mike Simpson ASU | DEC 5-0 | Mason Lenhard PENN |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J | PIN 5:40 | Juan Sanchez VMI |
| Dan Pacitti UNCG | DEC 7-3 | Mike Stanley EIU |
| Twan Pham ILL | DEC 5-3 | Matt Shankey IOWA |
| Twan Pham ILL | DEC 3-1 | Chris Rodrigues UNC |
| Brandon Newill PITT-J | DEC 3-0 | Tom Noto HOF |
| Semifinal |
| Alexis Vila Unattached | DEC 9-2 | Mason Lenhard PENN |
| Leroy Vega MINN | DEC 5-3 | Luke Eustice IOWA |
| Quarterfinal |
| Alexis Vila Unattached | DEC 14-10 | Ty Malia ISU |
| Leroy Vega MINN | DEC 3-2 | Mike Simpson ASU |
| Luke Eustice IOWA | DEC 5-3 | Tom Noto HOF |
| Mason Lenhard PENN | DEC 3-2 | Chris Williams MSU |
| Round of 16 |
| Mike Simpson ASU | DEC 5-1 | Twan Pham ILL |
| Chris Williams MSU | DEC 8-6 | Tom Combes Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| Leroy Vega MINN | DEC 6-4 | Jesse Leng OSU |
| Mason Lenhard PENN | DEC 1-1 | Jerold Limongelli RIDER |
| Alexis Vila Unattached | DEC 13-6 | Erkin Tadzhimetov UCM |
| Luke Eustice IOWA | DEC 6-2 | Rocco Mansueto Cleveland State University |
| Tom Noto HOF | DEC 11-5 | Jason Borrelli CMU |
| Ty Malia ISU | FORFEIT | Greg Schaefer IND |
| Round of 32 |
| Tom Noto HOF | MAJ DEC 20-9 | Nathan Peterson STAN |
| Ty Malia ISU | DEC 11-6 | Justin McClintock Iowa Central Community College |
| Erkin Tadzhimetov UCM | PIN 3:34 | Michel Moharreri Lincoln College |
| Greg Schaefer IND | DEC 2-1 | Chris Rodrigues UNC |
| Tom Combes Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 10-5 | Terrance Clendenin Unattached |
| Leroy Vega MINN | DEC 9-3 | Michael Delaney ORST |
| Jesse Leng OSU | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Robert Potashnick NW |
| Alexis Vila Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Matt Shankey IOWA |
| Mike Simpson ASU | DEC 9-4 | Brandon Newill PITT-J |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Jesse Leng OSU | DEC 3-2 | Vic Moreno CSUB |
| Ty Malia ISU | PIN 1:29 | Dan Pacitti UNCG |
| Nathan Peterson STAN | PIN 3:51 | Andy Gleixner MacMurray College |
| Jerold Limongelli RIDER | PIN 3:51 | Juan Sanchez VMI |
