| Finals |
| T.J. Williams IOWA1st | DEC 4-2 | Chris Bono2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Brett Matter3rd | — | Bryan Snyder NEB4th |
| Brett Matter3rd | DEC 3-1 | Gray Maynard MSU6th |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club5th | — | Gray Maynard MSU6th |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club5th | FORFEIT | Gray Maynard MSU6th |
| Shaun Shapert EDIN7th | — | Nathan Vasquez8th |
| Consi Semi |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club | FORFEIT | Dom Dellagatta |
| Gray Maynard MSU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Gent Powell ILL |
| Nathan Vasquez | DEC 4-0 | Cole Sanderson ISU |
| Shaun Shapert EDIN | DEC 4-2 | Shad Benton |
| Semifinal |
| T.J. Williams IOWA | DEC 5-3 | Brett Matter |
| Chris Bono | DEC 4-2 | Bryan Snyder NEB |
| Consi 4 |
| Gray Maynard MSU | DEC 3-2 | Kevin Kurtz HARV |
| Shaun Shapert EDIN | DEC 5-1 | Leo Urbinelli COR |
| Dom Dellagatta | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Dennis Papadatos HOF |
| Nathan Vasquez | DEC 3-1 | Mike Ziska PITT |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Kevin Kurtz HARV | DEC 8-4 | Chris Vitale LEH |
| Gray Maynard MSU | MAJ DEC 24-13 | Matt Veach Lincoln College |
| Gray Maynard MSU | DEC 5-3 | Nathan Vasquez |
| Leo Urbinelli COR | DEC 3-2 | Nick Frost ASU |
| Mike Ziska PITT | DEC 7-0 | Frank DeFilippis EIU |
| Nathan Vasquez | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Mike Kelly EIU |
| Shaun Shapert EDIN | DEC 7-4 | Brandon Gibbs Cleveland State University |
| Dom Dellagatta | DEC 6-0 | Ben Boozer EDIN |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 7-5 | Bryan Snyder NEB |
| Dennis Papadatos |
| Quarterfinal |
| Brett Matter | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| Bryan Snyder NEB | DEC 3-2 | Gent Powell ILL |
| Chris Bono | DEC 3-2 | Cole Sanderson ISU |
| T.J. Williams IOWA | TF 18-2 | Shad Benton |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Gray Maynard MSU | DEC 6-5 | Tony Holifield MICH |
| Mike Kelly EIU | DEC 6-4 | Shane McChesney CLAR |
| Nick Frost ASU | DEC 6-5 | Brian Wood WYO |
| Kevin Kurtz HARV | DEC 3-1 | Doug Cieleski SRU |
| Frank DeFilippis EIU | DEC 7-3 | Greg Fox |
| Shaun Shapert EDIN | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Steve Joseph EDIN |
| Ben Boozer EDIN | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Nastasi |
| Dennis Papadatos HOF | MAJ DEC 15-5 | Bobby Mantle IOWA |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Nastasi | PIN 1:24 | Decher VMI |
| Gray Maynard MSU | MAJ DEC 15-7 | Dennis Landin UNC |
| Brian Wood WYO | MAJ DEC 17-6 | Jonathan Friedstat NW |
| Nick Frost ASU | DEC 8-2 | Russell Clark CMU |
| Bobby Mantle IOWA | DEC 9-2 | Shawn Harmon STAN |
| Kevin Kurtz HARV | DEC 5-1 | Luc Dyer NIU |
| Tony Holifield MICH | DEC 6-4 | Josh Wheeler San Francisco State University |
| Greg Fox | DEC 6-5 | Warren McPherson STAN |
| Frank DeFilippis EIU | DEC 5-4 | Nate Lukanich University of Chicago |
| Shane McChesney |
| Round of 16 |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 5-2 | Chris Vitale LEH |
| Brett Matter | MAJ DEC 14-1 | Matt Veach Lincoln College |
| Shad Benton | DEC 9-7 | Nathan Vasquez CSUB |
| Bryan Snyder NEB | DEC 8-2 | Dom Dellagatta Montclair State University |
| Cole Sanderson ISU | DEC 4-2 | Brandon Gibbs Cleveland State University |
| Chris Bono | DEC 10-5 | Leo Urbinelli COR |
| T.J. Williams IOWA | TF 25-10 | Mike Ziska PITT |
| Gent Powell ILL | DEFAULT 4:52 | Matt Merrill |
| Round of 32 |
| Brett Matter | PIN 3:23 | Mike Pater NIU |
| Dom Dellagatta Montclair State University | PIN | Mark Churella MICH |
| Cole Sanderson ISU | PIN 2:59 | Dennis Landin UNC |
| Mike Ziska PITT | DEC 5-2 | Dennis Papadatos HOF |
| Nathan Vasquez CSUB | DEC 8-1 | Tony Holifield MICH |
| Shad Benton | DEC 11-6 | Ben Boozer EDIN |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club | MAJ DEC 17-5 | Greg Fox UNCG |
| Matt Veach Lincoln College | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Steve Joseph EDIN |
| Bryan Snyder NEB | MAJ DEC 16-8 | Shaun Shapert |
