| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Brett Matter | PIN 3:23 | Mike Pater NIU |
| Dom Dellagatta Montclair State University | PIN | Mark Churella MICH |
| Cole Sanderson ISU | PIN 2:59 | Dennis Landin UNC |
| Mike Ziska PITT | DEC 5-2 | Dennis Papadatos HOF |
| Nathan Vasquez CSUB | DEC 8-1 | Tony Holifield MICH |
| Shad Benton | DEC 11-6 | Ben Boozer EDIN |
| Alex Coriano Wildcat Wrestling Club | MAJ DEC 17-5 | Greg Fox UNCG |
| Matt Veach Lincoln College | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Steve Joseph EDIN |
| Bryan Snyder NEB | MAJ DEC 16-8 | Shaun Shapert EDIN |
| Matt Merrill | DEC 12-10 | Nate Lukanich University of Chicago |
| Brandon Gibbs Cleveland State University | DEC 5-3 | Josh Wheeler San Francisco State University |
| Gent Powell ILL | DEC 4-3 | Warren McPherson STAN |
| Leo Urbinelli COR | DEC 9-3 | Luc Dyer NIU |
| Chris Bono | DEC 12-5 | Doug Cieleski SRU |
| Chris Vitale LEH | TF 20-5 | Frank DeFilippis EIU |
| T.J. Williams IOWA | TF 21-6 | Ryan Fasnacht BUCK |