| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail |
| Jason Carr Manchester University | — | Chris Whetstone San Francisco State University |
| Jeff Freidhof Luther College | — | Carl Fronhofer PITT |
| Tim Hoff EMU | — | Pat Kennedy IOWA |
| Jamie Groudle UNC | — | Kyle Fisher |
| Yanni Diamond EDIN | — | Jeff Stewart IOWA |
| Jason Wilson UNC | — | Bill Garrett Hawkeye Wrestling Club |
| Bill Zeman ILL | — | Clint Wattenberg COR |
| Steven Blackford ASU | TF 16-1 | Greg Parker PRIN |
| Jamie Groudle UNC | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Greg DeGrand MSU |
| Tod Surmon Dave Schultz WC | DEC 9-7 | Noel Thompson HOF |
| Terry Murphy Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 8-7 | Tim Bonebright |
| Tim Ortman PENN | DEC 8-5 | Sam Smith Lincoln College |
| Joey Killar HARV | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Jason Rawls MICH |
| Jeff Freidhof Luther College | DEC 6-0 | Tony Scacco NW |
| Matt Erwin VMI | DEC 6-4 | Matt Hand IOWA |
| Heath Eslinger | DEC 4-3 | Joel Walker OSU |
| Matt Lackey ILL | DEC 7-5 | Travis Doto LEH |
| Clay Hackerman STAN | DEC 4-2 | Tim Hoff EMU |
| Jason Ramstetter | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Bill Lowney NIU |
| Yanni Diamond EDIN | DEC 4-1 | Brad Keeney |
| Ian Nelms CSUB | DEC 6-4 | Bill Zeman ILL |
| Tim Ortman PENN | DEC 3-1 | Vernon Cannon CMU |
| Matt Anderson IOWA | DEC 3-1 | Jason Carr Manchester University |