| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Dale Griffin VMI | PIN 3:35 | Brian Falciglia BUCK |
| Kevin Welsh EDIN | DEC 7-2 | Rob Anspach HOF |
| Dax Pecaro UNCG | MAJ DEC 14-4 | Josh Greenspan Cleveland State University |
| Tom Ciezki NW | DEC 13-6 | Jesse Smith IOWA |
| Rust Aizenberg COR | DEC 9-5 | Andy Hrovat MICH |
| Todd Miller EIU | DEC 3-1 | Travis Kraft EMU |
| Shawn Scannell RIDER | DEC 5-1 | Rob Anspach HOF |
| Will McCleve ASU | PIN | David Spangler IOWA |
| David Potter NIU | PIN 4:40 | Josh Greenspan Cleveland State University |
| Nate Patrick ILL | TF 20-5 | Nick Richmond UNC |
| Nick Richmond UNC | FORFEIT | Rob Rohn LEH |