| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Cash Edwards BSU | PIN 5:45 | David Schenk WYO |
| Ben McCrillis AIC | PIN 1:43 | Jason Schellenberg UNCO |
| Jason Rossotti California State University, Fresno | DEC 7-2 | Pat Kuznia COLU |
| Lionel Halsey CSUB | PIN 1:01 | Muhammed Lawal University of Central Oklahoma |
| Scott Jenkins AF | DEC 2-0 | Ryan Swanson Colorado School of Mines |
| Aaron Mitchell CLAR | DEC 6-3 | Reggie Lee HARV |
| Fabian Sciullo PITT | FORFEIT | Tyler Lunn POLY |
| Isaac Weber ORST | DEC 3-2 | Karl Rittger BRWN |
| Joe Terrill WIS | DEC 3-0 | Ty Michaelson Central Washington University |
| Dan Sturgell Southern Oregon University | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Matt Tyrrell University of Findlay |
| Josh States BUFF | DEC 4-3 | Travis Kraft EMU |
| Conrad Johnson Adams State | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Adam Turner GMU |
| Lance Thury SDSU | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Joe Potts Missouri Valley College |
| David Cobb UCD | PIN 3:27 | Danny Stevens San Francisco State University |