| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals |
| Jody Strittmatter PITT-J1st | DEC 10-3 | Steve Doerrer ILL2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club3rd | DEC 7-1 | Matt Azevedo ASU4th |
| Justin Bravo PENN5th | DEC 9-4 | Tom Combes EIU6th |
| Kenny Cox UO7th | DEFAULT | Davon Gray CMU8th |
| Consolation | ||
| Max Schurkamp San Francisco State University | DEC 6-3 | Twan Pham NIU |
| Dean Martinez Lincoln College | DEC 12-6 | Marc Juergens IOWA |
| Aaron Taylor COR | DEC 1-1 | Chad Hay ILL |
| Oliver Ruiz VMI | DEC 11-5 | Robert Potashnick NW |
| Jeff Jezuit University of Chicago | DEC 8-4 | Rafael Mejia EIU |
| Patrick Carey EMU | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Rudy Ruiz STAN |
| Justin Bravo PENN | DEC 9-4 | Phil Mansueto Cleveland State University |
| Jesse West ISU | DEC 5-1 | Randall Braunfeld PENN |
| Max Schurkamp San Francisco State University | DEC 5-1 | Dominic Caruso NW |
| Dean Martinez Lincoln College | DEC 16-10 | Charlie Soto EDIN |
| Chris Williams MSU | DEC 7-0 | Oliver Ruiz VMI |
| Ahmad Sanders CMU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Jeff Jezuit University of Chicago |
| Willie Harris AU | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Patrick Carey EMU |
| Justin Bravo PENN | PIN 3:16 | Todd Boemer BUCK |
| Jason Gabrielson EDIN | DEC 1-1 | Jesse West ISU |
| Max Schurkamp San Francisco State University | DEC 3-2 | Dean Martinez Lincoln College |
| Chris Williams MSU | DEC 11-4 | Aaron Taylor COR |
| Ahmad Sanders CMU | DEC 7-1 | Willie Harris AU |
| Justin Bravo PENN | DEC 11-6 | Jason Gabrielson EDIN |
| Davon Gray CMU | PIN 3:55 | Max Schurkamp San Francisco State University |
| Matt Azevedo ASU | DEC 3-1 | Chris Williams MSU |
| Kenny Cox UO | DEC 5-3 | Ahmad Sanders CMU |
| Justin Bravo PENN | DEFAULT | Bruce Kelly LEH |
| Matt Azevedo ASU | DEC 4-2 | Davon Gray CMU |
| Justin Bravo PENN | DEC 9-4 | Kenny Cox UO |
| Matt Azevedo ASU | DEC 6-3 | Tom Combes EIU |
| Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 12-6 | Justin Bravo PENN |
| Semifinal | ||
| Jody Strittmatter PITT-J | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Tom Combes EIU |
| Steve Doerrer ILL | DEC 7-5 | Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Tom Combes EIU | MAJ DEC 19-10 | Kenny Cox UO |
| Jody Strittmatter PITT-J | PIN 4:59 | Bruce Kelly LEH |
| Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Davon Gray CMU |
| Steve Doerrer ILL | DEC 1-0 | Matt Azevedo ASU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Tom Combes EIU | DEC 11-4 | Chad Hay ILL |
| Kenny Cox UO | DEC 11-7 | Chris Williams MSU |
| Bruce Kelly LEH | DEC 12-9 | Dominic Caruso NW |
| Jody Strittmatter PITT-J | PIN 1:59 | Charlie Soto EDIN |
| Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club | TF 16-0 | Todd Boemer BUCK |
| Davon Gray CMU | DEC 9-8 | Jason Gabrielson EDIN |
| Steve Doerrer ILL | DEC 9-4 | Ahmad Sanders CMU |
| Matt Azevedo ASU | MAJ DEC 15-3 | Willie Harris AU |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Tom Combes EIU | DEC 4-3 | Jesse West ISU |
| Chad Hay ILL | DEC 6-4 | Randall Braunfeld PENN |
| Kenny Cox UO | DEC 8-4 | Phil Mansueto Cleveland State University |
| Chris Williams MSU | DEC 9-2 | Justin Bravo PENN |
| Bruce Kelly LEH | DEC 16-10 | Patrick Carey EMU |
| Dominic Caruso NW | DEC 5-2 | Rudy Ruiz STAN |
| Charlie Soto EDIN | DEC 8-4 | Rafael Mejia EIU |
| Jody Strittmatter PITT-J | PIN 5:10 | Jeff Jezuit University of Chicago |
| Tim Dernlan Wildcat Wrestling Club | TF 15-0 | Robert Potashnick NW |
| Todd Boemer BUCK | DEC 9-4 | Oliver Ruiz VMI |
| Davon Gray CMU | DEC 4-2 | Aaron Taylor COR |
| Steve Doerrer ILL | DEC 12-5 | Dean Martinez Lincoln College |
| Ahmad Sanders CMU | DEC 6-3 | Marc Juergens IOWA |
| Willie Harris AU | DEC 8-6 | Twan Pham NIU |
| Matt Azevedo ASU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Max Schurkamp San Francisco State University |