| Scott Kelly NAVY1st |
| DEC 5-2 |
| Leland Rogers CUSE2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Dan Costigan ARMY3rd | DEC 8-3 | Steve Hasenfus COLU4th |
| Steve Salzman YALE5th | DEC 4-3 | Rob Garwood PRIN6th |
| Rob Nusum FM7th | — | Kelly Flynn HARV8th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Steve Hasenfus COLU | DEC 5-1 | Rob Garwood PRIN |
| Dan Costigan ARMY | DEC 12-7 | Steve Salzman YALE |
| Semifinal | ||
| Scott Kelly NAVY | PIN 0:59 | Steve Hasenfus COLU |
| Leland Rogers CUSE | DEC 6-2 | Dan Costigan ARMY |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Steve Salzman YALE | DEC 4-3 | Rob Nusum FM |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Rob Garwood PRIN | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Paul Tirjan PENN |
| Kelly Flynn HARV | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Dan Sanchez Wilkes University |
| Steve Salzman YALE | DEC 3-1 | Peter Rushmeier BRWN |
| Rob Nusum FM | DEC 10-5 | Tim Anderson COR |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Steve Salzman YALE | PIN 0:52 | Rob Nusum FM |
| Rob Garwood PRIN | DEC 2-1 | Kelly Flynn HARV |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Kelly Flynn HARV | DEC 4-1 | Joe Barnum RU |
| Tim Anderson COR | MAJ DEC 25-11 | Todd McClelland East Stroudsburg University |
| Paul Tirjan PENN | PIN 4:53 | Mike Ekberg LEH |
| Peter Rushmeier BRWN | PIN 3:03 | Sam Roots W&M |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Scott Kelly NAVY | PIN 0:54 | Rob Nusum FM |
| Leland Rogers CUSE | TF 17-1 | Dan Sanchez Wilkes University |
| Steve Hasenfus COLU | DEC 7-3 | Steve Salzman YALE |
| Dan Costigan ARMY | DEC 6-3 | Rob Garwood PRIN |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Scott Kelly NAVY | PIN 1:43 | Mike Ekberg LEH |
| Steve Hasenfus COLU | PIN 6:29 | Joe Barnum RU |
| Leland Rogers CUSE | PIN 1:30 | Sam Roots W&M |
| Dan Costigan ARMY | PIN 1:43 | Todd McClelland East Stroudsburg University |
| Rob Nusum FM | MAJ DEC 19-6 | Paul Tirjan PENN |
| Steve Salzman YALE | DEC 6-3 | Kelly Flynn HARV |
| Rob Garwood PRIN | MAJ DEC 16-5 | Tim Anderson COR |
| Dan Sanchez Wilkes University | DEC 8-4 | Peter Rushmeier BRWN |
