| DEC 14-9 |
| Frank Shaffer NAVY2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Dave Galdi COLU3rd | DEC 12-9 | Ned Pelger PRIN4th |
| Tom Sloand LEH5th | DEC 8-2 | Hal Fullmer PENN6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Dave Galdi COLU | DEC 3-2 | Hal Fullmer PENN |
| Ned Pelger PRIN | DEFAULT 4:16 | Tom Sloand LEH |
| Semifinal | ||
| Chris Catalfo CUSE | PIN 7:11 | Ned Pelger PRIN |
| Frank Shaffer NAVY | DEC 8-4 | Dave Galdi COLU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Tom Sloand LEH | DEC 8-2 | Paul Meyers YALE |
| Hal Fullmer PENN | — | Jason Rushton ARMY |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Tom Sloand LEH | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Jim Johnson Wilkes University |
| Paul Meyers YALE | — | Mike Skalla Colgate University |
| Hal Fullmer PENN | DEC 11-7 | Jon Tush East Stroudsburg University |
| Jason Rushton ARMY | DEC 15-8 | Bryan Baer HARV |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Tom Sloand LEH | PIN 4:05 | Bryan Baer HARV |
| Hal Fullmer PENN | DEC 12-6 | Jason Rushton ARMY |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Bryan Baer HARV | DEC 11-4 | Doug LaGarde W&M |
| Jon Tush East Stroudsburg University | — | George Kacandes FM |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Chris Catalfo CUSE | PIN 3:32 | Hal Fullmer PENN |
| Dave Galdi COLU | DEC 9-5 | Paul Meyers YALE |
| Frank Shaffer NAVY | DEC 5-2 | Tom Sloand LEH |
| Ned Pelger PRIN | DEC 7-2 | Jason Rushton ARMY |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Chris Catalfo CUSE | PIN 3:22 | Mike Ramos TEMPLE |
| Frank Shaffer NAVY | PIN 5:34 | Jon Tush East Stroudsburg University |
| Dave Galdi COLU | PIN 4:17 | Bryan Baer HARV |
| Tom Sloand LEH | DEC 11-8 | George Kacandes FM |
| Jason Rushton ARMY | DEC 6-5 | Mike Skalla Colgate University |
| Ned Pelger PRIN | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Karl Mulle COR |
| Hal Fullmer PENN | DEC 16-13 | Jim Johnson Wilkes University |
| Paul Meyers YALE | DEC 10-4 | Doug LaGarde W&M |
