| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Al Lilley TEMPLE | PIN 5:01 | Jim Bedell |
| Ed Franquemont HARV | PIN 6:46 | John Boyd PENN |
| Dick DeWalt PSU | PIN 2:23 | Hayward YALE |
| Clair Riley PITT | DEC 5-2 | Lawrence Nelson COLU |
| Tom Muir LEH | DEFAULT | Steve Sinatra FM |
| Gene O'Donnell RU | DEC 7-1 | Tom Southworth COR |
| Ray Sepata ARMY | MAJ DEC 17-6 | Jim Connerton Colgate University |
| John Kent NAVY | DEC 6-4 | Dave Hierbaum CUSE |