| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| John Johnston PSU1st | DEC 6-3 | Vic DeFelice PITT2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Leon Harbold LEH3rd | DEC 4-3 | |
| Jerry Weisenseel ARMY4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| John Johnston PSU | PIN 4:43 | Leon Harbold LEH |
| Vic DeFelice PITT | DEC 8-3 | Jerry Weisenseel ARMY |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| John Johnston PSU | PIN 3:46 | George Willis COR |
| Vic DeFelice PITT | DEC 8-2 | Steve Saltzman FM |
| Jerry Weisenseel ARMY | DEC 3-0 | George Seaver BRWN |
| Leon Harbold LEH | DEFAULT | Ed Carlin CUSE |
| Round of 16 | ||
| John Johnston PSU | PIN 6:24 | Paul Striker HARV |
| George Seaver BRWN | PIN 6:30 | Dick Bakalor COLU |
| Vic DeFelice PITT | PIN 3:30 | Bob Hamada YALE |
| Ed Carlin CUSE | DEC 7-0 | Dick McShane Colgate University |
| Steve Saltzman FM | DEC 2-1 | George McLaughlin PRIN |
| Leon Harbold LEH | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Robert Green NAVY |
| George Willis COR | DEC 9-4 | Dick McKeeby RU |
| Jerry Weisenseel ARMY | DEC 5-0 | Wilfred Chassey Springfield College |