| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| David Clark COLU | PIN 2:56 | Sam Underhill NAVY |
| Ed Peery PITT | PIN 3:18 | Charles Hershey FM |
| Sid Nodland | ||
| PIN 4:29 |
| Jud Ellis ARMY |
| George Creason CUSE | PIN 4:44 | Phil Schrefer YALE |
| Bob Myers LEH | PIN 4:38 | Paul Martin Colgate University |
| Charles Hershey FM | PIN 4:36 | Ed Hoffman RU |
| John Cummings BRWN | DEC 5-4 | Carmon Molino COR |
| Edward Amerantes Springfield College | DEC 5-0 | Dave Moulton PRIN |
| Art McCall TEMPLE | DEC 7-5 | David Skeels HARV |