| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH1st | PIN 2:08 | Dave Adams PSU2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Richard Simmons TEMPLE3rd | DEC 7-3 | |
| Bill Fortenbaugh PRIN4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| Dave Adams PSU | DEC 4-2 | Richard Simmons TEMPLE |
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | DEC 11-4 | Bill Fortenbaugh PRIN |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Dave Adams PSU | PIN 7:58 | Bob Bubb PITT |
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | TF 16-1 | Thomas King CUSE |
| Richard Simmons TEMPLE | DEC 7-2 | Joe Muse BRWN |
| Bill Fortenbaugh PRIN | DEC 3-1 | Bob Daughenbaugh NAVY |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | PIN 5:40 | Dwight Conklin RU |
| Richard Simmons TEMPLE | PIN 3:40 | George Lemmond Colgate University |
| Dave Adams PSU | PIN 4:55 | Dave Kinne COLU |
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | MAJ DEC 17-3 | Ken Fisher PENN |
| Joe Muse BRWN | DEC 5-2 | Henry Bianowicz Springfield College |
| Bob Daughenbaugh NAVY | DEC 6-4 | Phil Hepner YALE |
| Thomas King CUSE | DEC 5-3 | Dick Vincent COR |
| Bob Bubb PITT | DEC 5-4 | D. Horner FM |
| Bill Fortenbaugh PRIN | DEC 5-4 | Russell Harris ARMY |