| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Sid Nodland PSU1st | DEC 1-1 | Bill Hulings PITT2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Gene D'Alessandro RU3rd | FORFEIT | |
| George Creason CUSE4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| Sid Nodland PSU | DEC 5-1 | Gene D'Alessandro RU |
| Bill Hulings PITT | DEC 9-2 | George Creason CUSE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| George Creason CUSE | PIN 5:50 | Tom Deppe LEH |
| Bill Hulings PITT | DEC 3-1 | Carmon Molino COR |
| Sid Nodland PSU | DEC 6-3 | Gerry Yoder FM |
| Gene D'Alessandro RU | DEC 9-4 | Andy Fitch YALE |
| Round of 16 | ||
| George Creason CUSE | PIN 6:25 | Jud Ellis ARMY |
| Bill Hulings PITT | PIN 1:20 | Dick Ward BRWN |
| Sid Nodland PSU | PIN 3:40 | Dick Nathan PENN |
| Gerry Yoder FM | PIN 5:50 | Dick Osborne PRIN |
| Gene D'Alessandro RU | DEC 9-5 | Marshall Masterson NAVY |
| Carmon Molino COR | DEC 6-0 | Arima HARV |