| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Phil Brainerd NAVY | PIN 2:23 | Tony Tsocanos Colgate University |
| Neal Lesher RU | PIN 8:04 | Harrison Springfield College |
| Bob Gilmore | ||
| PIN 6:46 |
| R. Johnson COLU |
| Tex Lenart ARMY | PIN 7:38 | Ron Vaughn LEH |
| Hugn Sherrie TEMPLE | DEC 9-8 | Roger Hinkson YALE |
| Jay Goldenberg PENN | DEC 17-10 | Tex Lenart ARMY |
| Bill White CUSE | DEC 5-1 | Jack Kirkpatrick FM |
| Don Huff PITT | DEC 6-3 | Ed Nell PRIN |
| Bob Lynch COR | DEC 5-0 | Ernie Young PSU |